发新话题
打印

The BPS Research Digest Issue 116

本主题由 database 于 2008-6-5 16:41 移动

The BPS Research Digest Issue 116

________________________________________
$ a2 I+ Q5 q/ N+ z| The BPS Research Digest
! O: L  l9 p8 D2 e6 \8 f: Y+ p, c! k| Issue 116
: n9 g5 g( s3 I; c# Q| http://www.researchdigest.org.uk/blog% l3 R& S: h& h! p" ?2 [
| _______________________________________
# h$ N2 J. u5 d* j/ u2 c/ F* S
, \; m. P; f! Z2 c# x3 e. fSponsored by The Skills Development Service LTD - one of the UK's leading
" K' E1 j4 U; X& ^( p  Mproviders of one-day [url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url] training courses to NHS, Social Services and
7 O8 l7 j5 b  ~$ ?- j0 o/ E, bindependent practitioners. For our new seminar on reviewing your3 g* w. a. ?% O  A
understanding of depression and effective strategies in addressing it visit
$ U: ^% O0 s4 {. Q8 g9 S% Xhttp://www.skillsdevelopment.co.uk/seminars.php.# O9 j; d3 K7 u  f) a2 i; R/ y4 H
, _* Y& j  e* F  m
Put your text here instead and reach over 21,800 subscribers. Email8 @2 d4 {5 L+ j2 [8 Q% O
christianjarrett@gmail.com for rates.% C  k( g1 {: G' u
9 Q/ y5 G6 Z5 j6 L
---------------------------------------
. o( W. A( ~9 h9 B$ ^* @7 G- XContents
* R$ U4 q) T- h3 F7 G- |---------------------------------------
- Z' o) K+ U/ v* S$ G- v8 w# |& S) y' `; q; O0 A
1. Non-clinical community samples - just how non-clinical are they?
9 R- w5 G& X: V3 K) G6 m: o8 F* a2. Hearing music that isn't there
0 {, d/ b) a( w2 c3. Space is compressed by a fast turn of your head
. {+ b+ C9 [6 n; R4. It matters how much blood video games have in them" J- O+ J; O( @8 q6 o% U
5. The price of thinking "It would have been worse under Saddam"
# y5 Q' j2 q3 s, T$ B6. Is borderline personality really associated with enhanced empathy?8 V) w- ~' I2 G8 k; K1 ]5 k$ I
7. Link fest
2 }/ q' p  |. H; ^$ \8. Adverts - 1 New, scroll down to view
: R( W5 V$ S, Y& E, z) [3 H/ e8 A3 G! w7 [
Digest as PDF: http://tinyurl.com/qw4to
  H$ A9 }" E& D4 k3 ^# Q
4 H. ~; n3 q/ [* Z! ^) V! g! a. S---------------------------------------
/ @- K7 C' E1 f- T* H3 PSociety information
. p* q5 T/ J" Q! R* d$ B3 B---------------------------------------5 j. L: H7 x/ d& e, m  |: D
1 G, k2 y6 K% N9 a
9. How to join the BPS
7 ^5 L* @. [  g. E& w5 o10. May's Psychologist magazine, £4 for Digest readers/ free to members.  W, Z5 p; D7 z, X' V; k
11. Acknowledgments
9 D2 l1 g) x; k# q. n8 x) X
) L. o) F$ }5 [5 E
( Y7 s& C$ Z3 Y; }/ ?#######################################/ X5 L1 m: R" L) w. N3 d
) c- R& I% w- T, a% B/ D& X) `
The Research Digest is published fortnightly by the9 W9 k9 q; P7 Q7 I3 w
British Psychological Society
1 a; P7 n& x  U
( n2 T: I+ r6 `; z) f1 ~% u9 hEditor: Dr Christian Jarrett* A3 q$ j- g  m3 x# G  @
christianjarrett@gmail.com' {1 K: w# j8 Z( c' L. `
: h! {- m. V8 T' I; b
#######################################, o1 F0 e/ R9 l6 d" K& s2 o

! a4 x$ O9 `0 ?$ M& P----------------------------------------9 ^. R+ h7 V# u- F6 {" J6 v
1. Just how non-clinical are so-called 'non-clinical community samples'9 i9 C; a5 F/ Q1 q$ ~: |
----------------------------------------
8 Q1 l/ d# o) N. G" |$ @6 d; e1 p
A practice common to [url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url] research is to take some measure - let's say* w7 `# v7 L! i3 K) ?0 a# d5 |% x8 h2 D4 M
amount of support from friends and family - and to compare people with( i- ~: }. i& j" ]- ^+ {5 l0 W
mental health problems and people without mental health problems, on this
/ I+ J& F  Y* Imeasure. The trouble, according to Idia Thurston and her co-workers, is
( q) K! p* _& _! R% Jwhere to find people without mental health problems.6 Y. k- t2 E. H% F

+ x5 r4 m3 e/ B/ SThe tactic used by most researchers is to recruit from the wider community,0 S5 M  }8 T, F6 H
for example by advertising in the local paper. But Thurston's team argue a9 }+ F$ r9 |; j* H% L+ y! A
large proportion of the general community actually have their own mental3 o: Q9 |; Y7 @8 I& C! s) S- Z
health problems, and many of them are receiving therapy, something many
5 W; O% P7 ?# dresearchers fail to screen for. This means that what research papers: Y, P7 R$ Y* T# Q: }
describe as a "non-clinical community sample" may not be so "non-clinical"3 N% B/ a9 L: o, |  q
after all.3 I, J; U5 u5 f8 Z; d3 J- e
% y5 P& A( p) @! I+ C- C* r$ O& i
Thurston and her colleagues assessed 224 families recruited through adverts* L' m( Y, g9 A- d' B. W
in local newspapers in south eastern USA as part of a larger study. They! Q) x5 U0 m2 U' B3 ]1 t
found 11 per cent of the teenagers, 20 per cent of the mothers and 13 per# `/ n& g# G3 V7 @5 J
cent of the fathers met the diagnostic criteria for one or more psychiatric9 n4 t; C! }9 {) ~6 `9 T, e% x2 t
disorders. Moreover, 12 per cent of the teenagers, 20 per cent of the
8 X& }7 M. p. E2 o' Zmothers and 11 per cent of the fathers were currently in therapy. These two; I9 p8 d: _3 \
groups didn't completely overlap - for instance, there were 25 mothers who
: `8 b7 K5 o& M$ T; z' Tmet diagnostic criteria for a psychiatric disorder but who weren't in, h! [4 B8 Z! w% w) J! Y; Y
therapy.% B8 l/ ?& X3 i! s5 [2 Q3 b

6 ]) q1 @) r4 }4 R! [Thurston's team said their findings have implications for research validity.! H' M5 J0 c9 u+ Z  z
Differences previously identified between clinical and so-called
/ C% R3 \8 [2 \! ?/ O$ E" G9 h- n- Y/ V"non-clinical" groups may be caused by a factor other than the clinical
( M9 w3 l7 U8 n' A9 Sstatus of the two groups.
/ }8 Z- q( u9 t% g6 I. u5 R* r0 A: b( F* w/ k1 A
Researchers should screen their community participants to find out if they
* u3 R; F, o7 Zare currently experiencing mental distress or participating in therapy,# w+ U0 s  a! `6 w- \& M
Thurston's team advised. But as regards whether such participants should' `# j, {- `; w0 w0 C- H
then be excluded from research, Thurston and her colleagues said: "There is
( T: i8 l! y/ f6 R. I" g+ Hno perfect answer, but rather, researchers must weigh the costs and benefits* M& K) \  r/ L. w( M
of their exclusionary criteria in relation to the goals of the study."& w" f. T) P5 a# t, m8 d0 a8 \
_________________________________
+ v9 _- C  I# j8 A+ Q# h+ @4 w) V& V5 i5 @. V# Q1 K; Y
Thurston, I.B., Curley, J., Fields, S., Kamboukos, D., Rojas, A., Phares, V.
. U6 `+ P2 S  ^' w(2008). How nonclinical are community samples?. Journal of Community( ]& g( V5 l1 l  M& ~5 G7 v1 _1 T
[url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url], 36(4), 411-420. http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/jcop.20223/ c) `! E, N6 S7 Z; N
) U, m  }; p8 I3 w9 \2 T
Author weblink: [url=http://[url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url].usf.edu/people/graduate_students/]http://[url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url].usf.edu/people/graduate_students/[/url]& i$ G9 C* T# c4 Q$ N) |

6 k8 v: m# @8 C2 r2 `) t0 r*Visit the DIGEST BLOG: http://www.researchdigest.org.uk/blog to comment on, m- b& U- }- x" q
this research, search past items and discover more links.
1 c  M' b" R2 S, x* a3 \- m9 @8 u" p) m
In the A-level syllabus: See modules on research methods.2 _/ v( E9 n- ]( V, [

- ?2 d6 O  T# B5 m----------------------------------------! P0 w4 \6 k- O: w
2. Hearing music that isn't there, ?: F: t$ p; t" C9 G- P
----------------------------------------8 @) t+ ^2 G) O5 o- J5 G  w1 ?
! A/ x6 g3 a6 {& q/ O
You've probably been tormented by a catchy song playing over and over in
1 P* j8 `6 `6 ], t1 j, I* L6 ?your head. Spare a thought then for those people for whom this phenomenon is
8 F6 ]0 m/ @: F* Ataken to the next level: the song or songs sound real and they play round) h( c+ [" e2 F0 Y
the clock. They have what's called 'musical hallucinosis'.
3 C& o- `0 m8 l, z# I$ W
9 H2 R$ M0 s4 z' g+ d6 ]6 {Besides hearing music that isn't there, such people often have no other
/ D4 d$ q+ E7 g6 Dpsychological complaints. However, people with the condition often have a1 A' ^3 M- G  I) \
degree of deafness and now Ramon Mocellin and colleagues have outlined an
2 T. b9 I& b/ j. d7 zexplanation based on the idea that what these people are experiencing is
, [$ e. N& _" L0 wrather like an auditory phantom limb.
5 k$ f$ l4 s8 v8 Q9 q
0 O( a5 V% v( O6 L6 e8 h. DMocellin's group begin by describing three typical cases. Case one was an
0 q4 x3 y% Q5 |- p82-year-old patient who lived in a remote farm house. She reported loud! h1 c: v# D. p- g! V  ~
music to the police and even sent her husband driving round the, N) f; J9 f. G& ?
neighbourhood looking for the source. She eventually realised the music was% I& q. u# |0 |( Y' z/ b8 e% W
a 'trick of her imagination'. Apart from deafness, the woman had no other
9 ?1 B. U) P: Z% s0 wneurological or psychiatric abnormalities.5 E0 b9 `# Q7 B* k& S( p

1 l; ~" `. ?" i% ^% @Case two was a 62-year-old surfer. He heard the opening bars of Jimi
* B) @5 v% f& Z- E% L( t! g9 W+ tHendrix's Voodoo Child for six months, when there was really no sound there.
( Y6 v3 ?8 K' yThis man had mild deafness and smoked cannabis but otherwise had no other
: O) C: E6 c2 [  mrelevant medical history.# \1 r9 H6 w& k& D- `. _
/ D/ K. M. Q8 i; O# W% H1 J0 D- |
The last case, a 78-year-old, was profoundly deaf, had Alzheimer's disease% h3 C* I$ p7 l0 j8 Q/ @3 X
and lived in a care home. He heard hymns and songs that were popular in the: B: |8 S6 @  j3 E( f1 a
1940s and 50s. Although he had cognitive impairments associated with
( s5 O/ q6 h, @( X" ~dementia, he had no other psychotic symptoms besides hearing music that$ S9 _1 t+ _" X
wasn't there.
: T- H" {/ Z' T- a. K# h
' J4 k- {* j6 Q3 J- R# ?& ERamon Mocellin and his colleagues explained that people with musical/ G! _, H9 l6 H3 D- j/ l, G
hallucinosis generally realise that their auditory experiences are a trick
8 ~/ x/ _; J; j* Oof the mind, thus distinguishing their symptoms from the hallucinations8 C# Q0 H1 w& v8 |( \. S$ X
experienced by people with psychosis, who generally believe their unusual
* d4 p/ _; z* L2 L8 u9 Lperceptions are real.
0 L6 V) R$ Y; P1 ?; ]5 C
" F* e" O- C  y+ w" w% t7 bAs we've seen, musical hallucinosis is often associated with deafness and; i, @5 |' u. c. g8 B# E$ g
Mocellin's team think the condition may reflect the spontaneous, aberrant' G8 x* s1 |  e4 U
firing of those brain cells whose job is to process music, if there were any# `! R, _. l9 \$ U( a7 x
to be heard. Higher brain levels then seek to make sense of this spontaneous: l5 R) C; A- h
firing, often drawing on musical memories in the process - hence the common
. j: J! \1 n; @/ P% m- _' T- x5 aexperience of perceiving music from previous eras.: S; h4 s! m  ]/ n
_________________________________
1 P% k% R$ _! L9 [( T0 ~+ a
7 I  a- X  i( B7 R# i( C! N& Z# \2 D$ JMocellin, R., Walterfang, M., Velakoulis, D. (2008). Musical hallucinosis:
6 F% y0 \/ H0 \, O& k9 l" zcase reports and possible neurobiological models. Acta Neuropsychiatrica,- g8 `- H9 E/ p% ]/ W: }
20(2), 91-95. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1601-5215.2007.00255.x' I6 l) \3 L6 t$ M4 t  [( l% T$ \

& e3 |; |. L7 L9 e*Visit the DIGEST BLOG: http://www.researchdigest.org.uk/blog to comment on6 B' X. F: g! Y: f. |
this research, search past items and discover more links.7 B8 I) B. k/ j/ U8 f2 q) c
" C+ O. i2 x; N; k) Z$ Y* y
Further reading: Science writer Carl Zimmer wrote about musical hallucinosis
6 }* `# K# |/ Rfor The Sunday Telegraph in 2004 http://tinyurl.com/6a3hko8 P, T+ q2 [. C* C+ R( |

7 u1 q- ^5 Z- }; W: t# ?  r/ b----------------------------------------
5 U' u- H' h$ x( @. M2 y3 A3. Space is compressed by a fast turn of your head
9 n( A7 C$ }5 e& A. j( l  i/ y0 [----------------------------------------: h+ y2 X7 T; }/ k) o, v4 _
& B2 F3 b; P3 t' t' V# c
The raw immediacy of our waking lives leaves us feeling as though our five$ Q4 j1 r3 j( e7 _6 k0 |: B
senses give us a true, undistorted perception of the world. But a catalogue
8 G% C9 T& B2 Aof [url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url] experiments has shown this sense of experiencing the world "as# k8 W4 d, Q# ]7 }# \" P' ~9 {, K
it is" couldn't be further from the truth. Now with the latest demonstration
( k/ m0 p  Y( e! }6 i, Z1 yof the tricks our minds play, Johahn Leung and colleagues have reported that/ a" W* c& n( l. P
moving our heads fast has the effect of compressing auditory space - that1 o0 P( i: q5 \2 z% W& j8 _
is, sounds emitted just before a head turn are sucked perceptually towards
# R% Y2 x7 }( {: B' ?; y9 N7 S* \9 d' lthe target of the head movement.5 i% Z9 a7 X9 [  o8 h6 T' o5 }

1 p5 F# x8 o6 f7 I+ DParticipants held their bodies still while shifting their heads as fast as
1 g7 n+ u) Y- E9 T6 v, Bpossible to a light that appeared either 30 degrees to the left or right.4 I+ A: d6 d+ v- ~" N& X5 L" u, m
Just before the start of their head turn, a sound was emitted from a mobile* _. X7 w* w) Y: x1 U3 F
speaker that could be located a range of distances beyond or nearer than the
* N  L6 A, X5 j$ }5 O: Ilight. Judged against a second comparison sound, the participants8 j" {3 i) ~+ k& e9 D
consistently mislocated the first sound as being nearer the target of their& W9 y9 E3 g- z- E! Z
head turn than it really was. It's as though auditory space was compressed. [4 p: U' D* s. ^( R/ B
towards the light at the moment just before they moved their heads.
  E1 ]; e; c# W& A, p( c* K/ ~* ~7 E5 {; Q3 C# k" n
The finding replicates a similar spatial compression effect that occurs just
' f% o& \" S; k9 Xbefore people make fast saccadic eye movements. In this case, experts think- l% B2 l" I) J" g; N$ p; h
the compression is caused by brain cells adjusting their receptive fields in6 w6 d1 [' b! S( o- `; b
anticipation of where the eyes are going to be pointing after they've
: _0 M- m9 g$ Q. P, gfinished moving. Leung and colleagues said a similar process probably( B; i- O$ N& P; L4 G
explains the current findings.  \; y, I: L$ r1 n
: w) J' ], b1 y1 {; W+ `+ d
In a final twist, the compression of auditory space didn't occur if  p; Q* @& g" g1 Y
participants indicated the location of the sound by pointing their nose in* A/ S. z# U- E+ _  f
its direction. Indicating the sound location in this way (rather than by
5 B0 L: ?. a% s8 N1 a2 d5 h" Dperceptual comparison with a second sound) probably relies on the brain's# _1 a, `. U0 c- q2 m- u
action pathway, which is known to be less affected by perceptual illusions.
. J3 A' L6 g  r  J5 g_________________________________4 E8 ]9 C' M9 j: p) J- a! m
2 H0 I- F8 o8 B: c+ S& p" k, H
Leung, J., Alais, D., Carlile, S. (2008). Compression of auditory space$ H6 Z. }' N4 M! h# n8 a
during rapid head turns. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.$ S9 N2 m0 l! w
http://dx.doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0710837105
  ]6 r! i* V) `" d5 g$ H1 j. m- j2 Q
; a5 ~9 S9 q6 V2 j8 @- ZAuthor weblink: http://www.linkedin.com/pub/0/20/34B
. j) l! _% E" @) p# [! I) U- C* A% C5 R. G+ V- G# j
*Visit the DIGEST BLOG: http://www.researchdigest.org.uk/blog to comment on( y9 i+ p5 i0 i, H- L' ?. U6 E/ U
this research, search past items and discover more links.
0 ]! v: ]. H8 o9 [& q' S, g8 L
  ]8 |+ \4 z" A" ^In the A-level syllabus: AQA spec A, A2, cognitive [url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url], attention and
8 ?% R/ f2 w- r' g  Bpattern recognition. AQA spec B, AS, cognitive [url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url], perception and
, J% y1 F1 D7 S4 J, ^) u2 V/ R9 tattention. SQA adv higher, cognitive [url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url], attention.9 b) [& H( d: i- ^+ j+ v
" q- _+ z. g: l" v5 Q
----------------------------------------1 t% n2 A4 K3 q% Q
4. It matters how much blood video games have in them
2 G& [0 J3 s9 M- E----------------------------------------
9 \) U+ K1 z) L$ ?2 h; S
2 W0 y: G+ M6 x& \1 A% W/ u% OHype surrounding the global release of the gangster-themed video game Grand
) J* a, Y9 R5 p# d6 v5 }2 I7 pTheft Auto IV has renewed the long-standing debate over whether violent
/ H( h# T( o5 u2 _4 Ygames make players more aggressive. Now Christopher Barlett and colleagues
; v% V4 h( h% z3 w7 t/ W9 [have provided a fresh angle on the issue by specifically testing whether the
1 D, ^* E. _6 _  `+ {1 ], Qamount of blood in a game makes any difference to its effects on aggression.
6 y5 g4 Y) `, A! j3 k0 K0 Q- F5 `4 }6 R$ q* M$ R
The researchers took advantage of the fact that the game Mortal Combat:
: c. D; H' J6 v0 P5 Q* FDeadly Alliance allows players to select one of four blood levels, from none4 p& ]" r* Z. s; @2 C( O
to maximum (in which copious amounts of blood spurts everywhere and gets
% n( K: i5 s( X+ e/ R/ Vtrodden by characters around the playing area).5 j9 k0 i: j" P' z4 }! Z
* X: t$ Y- o5 v6 _8 r
Of 74 students who played the Mortal Combat game for 15 minutes, those who7 O5 P& A" f7 U+ n+ r$ _
played on the maximum blood level experienced larger increases in hostility
5 I9 D) i1 Z; b" z% I2 _9 kafter playing (as judged by their agreement with statements like "I feel
! v7 R  W8 @5 z( e% n; u. ]( Mfurious") and larger increases in arousal as measured by their heart rate,
. ^: M7 }, V6 V7 ]3 J" O8 D- rthan did the players on the lower or zero blood levels.% B% M8 s% j3 g7 X) ]% p% G

8 O& P/ x6 G; O5 H  uThose students who played the game with blood also showed higher levels of) M% j3 u+ E# L. C$ N1 p5 I
aggression, compared with those who played without blood, as indicated by# x$ p5 F9 u6 ^4 I# a0 }; p
their greater use of their character's weapon in the game, which they'd been
! A! {0 H+ e# G6 p  [1 Vtold would inflict more damage on their opponents.
4 H5 w8 @5 a8 t
8 p" d$ [1 b/ G6 z  K" l2 tA second experiment with 31 students showed that playing Mortal Combat on
- q: [9 `" K. G+ }  ]9 Athe maximum blood level, as compared with the no blood level, activated more2 h3 D8 j+ c/ S' V5 P' z  z1 y" D
aggression related thoughts, as measured by participants' choice of how to  d' z( K9 v7 \( K. m! X% h
complete ambiguous word stems like KI-- (e.g. KILL vs. KISS).
' S, r& {3 S2 b! f3 u4 C$ Z' Y7 U4 Z' U1 d0 A4 W
"...[T]he violence, plus the high amount of blood, primes more aggressive
: }# z4 i6 z$ v$ Y& G4 pthoughts in memory compared with just playing the violent game without the
4 d1 Z& j/ t/ }. _- Y$ ablood," the researchers said.
' R6 E' p7 @- q8 h7 L$ `_________________________________
' L, w0 X" O- f! w/ Q: E3 h; }$ a* c  Y; I9 y4 q/ I7 A" ?
BARLETT, C., HARRIS, R., BRUEY, C. (2008). The effect of the amount of blood
3 Z3 F/ H: c6 n6 k) i5 b) g  h( Ein a violent video game on aggression, hostility, and arousal. Journal of
- |6 @& ]- U5 o" t# e1 jExperimental Social [url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url], 44(3), 539-546.+ q8 B% _% A" {$ a
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jesp.2007.10.003
3 V9 v1 a' Z' t4 e2 D- h4 [4 O3 G7 |' g$ O9 B) k+ ?
Author weblink: [url=http://www.[url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url].iastate.edu/index.php?id=98]http://www.[url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url].iastate.edu/index.php?id=98[/url]5 ^% O5 c( c  J2 W1 g9 t
/ O% h# _! L" F3 ~; S/ _1 r" ], b4 D
*Visit the DIGEST BLOG: http://www.researchdigest.org.uk/blog to comment on1 f( F9 I0 b  T
this research, search past items and discover more links.
' k' Q- \% R* z7 \4 t. Y1 l- L2 p1 A3 j* u. }+ K  S
In the A-level syllabus: AQA spec A, A2, social [url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url], pro and anti
0 u! F" K+ H1 Q" c( Jsocial behaviour, nature and causes of aggression. Edexcel, A2,& O: U8 m: R3 j3 Q/ _0 D
criminological [url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url], the effects of media on violence. SQA adv higher,- M' n# h) {% G9 V# ~8 e
social [url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url], anti social behaviour, media influences.( {% z3 S6 Z$ u- L

$ z! q7 m2 f; p----------------------------------------. e6 T5 n& m9 n& A, d+ O. j
5. The price of thinking "It would have been worse under Saddam"
5 v+ m4 B5 N/ @----------------------------------------
4 I4 R0 s/ J, K) d, d5 g. u3 G8 W" O. d% A
After news broke that US soldiers had mistreated their prisoners at the Abu
0 L/ x* L$ ^$ ?# j& q0 q% x$ ^' SGhraib jail in Iraq, a common reaction among pro-war politicians was to% {7 d) E4 ?" `1 g7 t
remind the public that: "It would have been worse under Saddam". Whatever+ _) U4 @8 f0 w7 X
the truth of this claim, new research suggests that comparing a current
! i! h8 Q' Y: I/ Vsituation with an even worse atrocity comes with a price - it desensitises# [- E7 y6 r% h, t4 m& o8 t
our judgment of future moral violations.0 d- `3 q* h+ Z5 _

" m- P* W% b# eForty student participants read an account of the atrocities committed by US
# N0 a) H6 P8 q9 ?! ]% {( r0 Mtroops at Abu Ghraib. A random subset of these students then read about the
* c" a% I! b% O: @/ btorture and executions that took place at the prison during Saddam Hussein's% f* x7 q9 X" z3 |; N
regime. Regardless of their own beliefs, they then had to compose an
# z0 ?4 ~9 d' l: ^# ~  `' Kargument for how conditions at the prison would have been worse under0 |0 M6 t) V0 c; M5 H/ N
Saddam's control. Other students, instead of reading about the prison under
2 O4 n' W$ k7 K9 O3 X+ l" k& O+ j/ FSaddam, read about an Iraqi prison run by Danish guards where captives were
+ ^% i2 b9 e1 P# Ctreated ethically. These students then had to compose an argument for how
6 j7 v: ?+ s1 h  othe standards of the Danish guards were better than the US guards. A control5 Z5 B, H+ Z, c6 b  Q  S5 D
group of students just read about the US troop atrocities.
% ^- I2 ~% }5 |/ z2 q; `
. v+ K; u' e& Y" KAfter all this, the students reported their own views on the US troop1 J: ?% a6 G9 J6 {
atrocities and they answered questions about how US troops should treat/ H+ ?8 j8 t& l9 C5 a0 k
prisoners in the future - for example, by stating whether or not they agreed
+ T! y4 m& b, a( b& bwith the use of torture to gain enemy information.# ^! W# k" \' k, Z) a

4 E0 P- ?1 X! F- U" [It turned out that the students who'd been asked to compare US-controlled' \9 d9 C- K! z2 v, M0 K2 q
Abu Ghraib conditions with conditions when under Saddam Hussein's control+ f3 N( z% ?7 _% v; [7 `0 b
subsequently reported more lenient views of the atrocities by US troops and,/ I- ^: f0 X7 z7 D4 u
most crucially, expressed lower ethical standards regarding how US troops
2 g$ H1 ?7 R1 K+ e) Lshould treat prisoners in the future, than did the control students and the9 z  S9 H. o2 S5 }
students who compared US with Danish prison standards.
' n2 I# w( c3 e) A
- ]4 B7 [2 G+ F' f4 k- C/ a- zKeith Markman and colleagues who conducted the research said: "Our point is
$ F6 k  F+ _# m+ L/ J3 v$ H  ~to question the usefulness of drawing a comparison between Abu Ghraib under
. y% E, n- w1 B& K# N0 |American control and Abu Ghraib under Saddam's control....t appears that
1 r9 T8 k( p# F- p& {/ Zthe contemplation of such a comparison lowers personal standards toward the
! q% g6 e/ ^. i  overy comparison standard against which one is seeking to contrast."
& G" b% q& |) I1 T) ]. v' K6 Q& E_________________________________
/ T- v  S1 G, F+ a' Q6 S6 H5 E
3 @/ t" ]# I, G+ o+ E5 eMARKMAN, K., MIZOGUCHI, N., MCMULLEN, M. (2008). "It would have been worse
  k4 M  |' T4 Munder Saddam": Implications of counterfactual thinking for beliefs regarding
2 l6 H8 I( p" Sthe ethical treatment of prisoners of war. Journal of Experimental Social0 O3 Z6 s0 U) l: w- F5 H
[url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url], 44(3), 650-654. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jesp.2007.03.005
1 A6 A% a& m8 o) I! O$ J' W/ i( J4 ?4 I/ P' _4 v9 x" `) n
Author weblink: [url=http://markman.social[url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url].org/]http://markman.social[url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url].org/[/url]
' b+ P/ j" C# s. ~1 G- V' A; h2 E6 m6 W% D% s+ o7 M
*Visit the DIGEST BLOG: http://www.researchdigest.org.uk/blog to comment on" [+ `! r! V" _" y. C; G
this research, search past items and discover more links.2 P3 p8 L1 Q2 ~' F$ T+ w( e9 V

  ^+ C) S5 _! F4 }0 M7 ?6 C; dFurther reading: See Markman, K.D. & McMullen, M.N. (2003). A reflection and' J: P8 O1 I0 P1 o! r" {, U
evaluation model of comparative thinking. Personality and Social [url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url]) S1 [: B  p5 U  x
Review, 7, 244-267.& p3 I' A4 @$ |& F% p# M  r9 D0 L
http://homepage.mac.com/danlassiter/.Public/Markman_REM.pdf
4 ?  L% }+ a1 @2 u- i3 U- q6 j2 O' c) ?9 l% C- H( h! m* O
----------------------------------------
  J5 d7 q1 \- W' t1 j6. Are people with borderline personality really more empathic?3 l" w9 l0 @+ @1 `: X
----------------------------------------
9 i8 n/ o& [. `
3 {3 m& h6 S; e+ G) L' t. jPeople with borderline personality disorder (BPD) are emotionally fragile,# ?/ b$ p2 [# v# F* H  Z* Y, k
impulsive, suffer from low mood, have intense unstable personal4 e& Z/ x! i* K* d' o9 v4 n$ b
relationships and - according to a handful of studies - they also have
6 u. \. s9 q* O$ K8 t% T# k) Senhanced empathy.
: b2 H7 C8 _7 o( `: E$ Q
+ N5 I; N; \; f5 _$ ~But new research by Judith Flury and colleagues shows the idea that BPD
/ a* s, d, Y/ C$ k$ h  \$ V: `patients have enhanced empathy is a spurious finding reflecting the
$ |7 M7 X# T* Y8 D$ u, S9 [methodological design of prior studies combined with the fact BPD patients4 ~$ S3 D$ ?* p* o6 L$ M- s" y
are particularly difficult to read.
% @4 E2 e7 g: a" B: Q4 v2 i# v" n9 f, O# q6 X1 o) ~
The 76 lowest and highest scorers on the Borderline Syndrome Index were
  Q3 L/ E  Z- P2 D0 }selected from among 789 students. These 76 were then arranged into pairs of
# {1 G1 W4 k7 i0 Nlow and high borderline participants. The members of each pair were videoed3 I9 \7 a4 t! F  Y  Q. `
chatting to each other for ten minutes, after which each person completed a! m' E! M5 I# x! o2 Z+ J+ d
personality questionnaire about themselves, and about how they thought their$ u0 T+ k6 ~( y) B/ q1 h" y, o
partner saw themselves. This latter part of the design mirrors the7 T0 u$ Z4 ?; d1 U$ k4 B& z
methodology of earlier studies that seemed to show BPD is associated with
9 E5 r3 r1 }5 X! j+ E: penhanced empathy.- z% Q! Z8 ~. y3 D  i
9 ?. x, n0 z) L
As in the earlier studies, it turned out that the high borderline students. K) U6 q* z. w7 C8 d
were better than the low borderline students at predicting how their' g: R- T7 L. M  `1 y+ R5 x
partners scored their own personalities - a sign of empathy, you'd think.1 n- y: \/ }9 E8 u! Z1 z
But further analysis showed that this finding was caused by the fact that/ x9 H4 q% A, K3 w6 M. h) i1 V& H
all the students tended to score their partners' personalities in a fairly2 f5 J4 X( m  V
stereotypical way. This tactic worked if a participant's partner was low; F% o$ M0 a0 o- A) v
borderline (with a less unusual personality profile), but not if they were! e2 E! b) x% N
high borderline with an unusual personality profile - hence the apparent
- @9 u5 `+ z8 R) X1 g# A, Q5 afinding that high borderline scorers are more empathic.
2 k  q6 X3 Q7 k2 X+ |
: g' C8 J" i& Y) ]/ Y+ I3 zThe students also watched the videos of themselves meeting their partners,  k2 ?& W/ n9 ]
and recorded the main thoughts and feelings they had experienced during the. F: ^: @% V+ ^; C8 D4 o' B) u
encounter. They then watched the video again and attempted to predict what
0 i4 C; E: a4 G) M4 \: [7 ftheir partner had reported thinking and feeling during the encounter. Again,
5 w( p* }4 c0 B( X! v; J5 ythe high borderline students scored better at this task, but as before, this
9 V( f) s) i. ysimply reflected the fact that within each of the student pairs, it was the
) E' y. |; Q0 r& \! T" k* }low borderline students who had the more predictable, less outlandish" m; G4 y! L0 l  ~
thoughts and feelings.
( O5 T3 L. b8 V2 ]" ?_________________________________& p/ u9 r3 b8 S7 ~% a, f- E! J1 d
5 ^4 U3 h* E% _4 }, |8 A
FLURY, J., ICKES, W., SCHWEINLE, W. (2008). The borderline empathy effect:
3 a, R4 l& M! N. K! F  T' n( sDo high BPD individuals have greater empathic ability? Or are they just more
" W& k# J3 {6 b( J( P. `3 Ndifficult to "read"? Journal of Research in Personality, 42(2), 312-332.
6 o6 \/ n8 M8 @, U# _. m6 E$ x' Vhttp://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jrp.2007.05.008
$ b: C6 l) \; h, `  \$ ?1 _/ y  k' g7 R+ M1 N; ~% k
Author weblink: [url=http://www.uta.edu/[url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url]/faculty/ickes/ickes.htm]http://www.uta.edu/[url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url]/faculty/ickes/ickes.htm[/url]- N5 r; k  Q. [; H1 h: E3 o& m

, u6 h( j. v; n$ T+ A*Visit the DIGEST BLOG: http://www.researchdigest.org.uk/blog to comment on
3 z' B1 R2 r# A; H! {, Zthis research, search past items and discover more links.: p( N7 \' ^+ ~# w

0 u$ J) X( q! E' u2 oFurther reading: Ladisich, W. & Feil, W.B. (1988). Empathy in psychiatric; f8 a7 E# _! G
patients. British Journal of Medical [url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url], 61, 155-162.
2 w' A* N# x+ F! v+ p- i& @* mhttp://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/3401423
: ?5 |$ U, M& m1 B3 f5 W; K  v% g: s; F  J8 Z" j4 w+ H+ F* {
----------------------------------------) m% s' [! {. v5 {: A7 `
7. Link fest
& k1 k" A% w! I/ w; U% t5 t----------------------------------------
0 H" T, k& A: w! [: c% P% s9 D0 X9 Q, V
For more of these links see the Digest blog:* \+ w& _* K$ t. _2 `" @4 C  F. D
http://www.researchdigest.org.uk/blog
* n$ A* s- Y7 i( M9 G+ S" v
' h. o. X8 r$ C7 ?% f* a3 t) ~THE SPECIAL ISSUE SPOTTER
$ ^4 c9 r# P' v4 T" u4 [4 W( l/ OVerbalising visual memories (European Journal of Cognitive [url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url]).8 t( A* ]! M8 l3 S! }
http://www.informaworld.com/smpp/title~content=g791897019
8 q4 @4 A* o9 l1 Z( l4 w8 ~" i  o' ?8 H- t- P- {8 O
EXTRAS
) Y/ C) Z- Z/ QMaking choices is mentally exhausting, such that it leaves us with less5 K0 Y1 u8 u8 R
self-control (pdf).
  V* A( X, A2 x* {  x+ d8 G8 A. v) d/ }http://www.carlsonschool.umn.edu/assets/113144.pdf
9 j  Y" h, h6 O* ]! b9 C: \) `( ?+ E* S& C! V9 m2 J& t! j
ELSEWHERE
* b2 p9 J2 Y: G8 A/ [2 T) u+ dHave psychotherapies been overhyped?! o. A, H7 g" m# z( g5 I
http://bps-research-digest.blogspot.com/2008/05/have-psychotherapies-been-overhyped.html1 o- b  t% Q6 f& g

* E" g9 Y* W1 _+ n. a----------------------------------------1 Z) b/ @) m. g8 s1 Q
8. *Advertisements*
; U6 C; d, y9 P/ E----------------------------------------
, a( \3 {* o, k--* R5 E2 x0 P" m1 l, w
[url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url] 4 Students
1 L# B. ?! m- w  |( a) MThe Manchester and London Lectures are each a one day event featuring some3 Y. q& O7 A! a0 w3 k
of the UK's top psychologists talking about what makes us think and act the
5 L. z% T; B( h& F9 {6 E% Xway we do. This event is aimed specifically at A-Level and Undergraduate! [% g7 |1 @% h/ D4 M- i- J$ }
students and costs only £15 to attend, which includes a packed lunch. For
5 m. M. Y3 K0 |5 i- ]more information, please visit http://www.bps.org.uk/manchester2008 or  |& t9 L. `3 k: ~& {  v
http://www.bps.org.uk/london2008 or call 0116 2529555" ~+ T2 f6 b( f1 r+ P& m: d2 W  R
--
  M& R' I( c0 N0 U! J1 a7 P# P/ O2 D4 P5 V6 c2 ~
Find out how you could reach 21,000 subscribers by
5 ?4 L% z* f- ~  ?/ badvertising in this slot, contact sarah.stainton@bps.org.uk
$ ?" O2 F6 y, a6 U+ |3 n& G' [( y' s- J/ x
----------------------------------------
) E4 B7 U+ f: Q4 R9 ?9. How to join the Society1 K' n% H3 }( j
----------------------------------------& b$ |- j9 E) F, j2 d8 K2 x

2 d9 [0 ]0 K& U( PStudent membership now open to A-level students, as well as undergrads, from
% E. s' {  t3 o£20 a year!
& n5 n8 b. I$ z9 o8 [$ c/ c2 G1 J/ s: Q) R% u; ]3 X6 D* t
Simply request an application pack via the BPS office:
, X  N: p  f5 c) o1 [* lTel. 0116 254 9568, Email enquiry@bps.org.uk* T, b" S1 u9 H. i
or visit http://www.bps.org.uk/membership/4 x8 `/ l4 I5 [4 ~8 i; B$ v+ s3 A2 X

# y* f7 @! L) {- aMembership of The Society offers students many benefits: THE
( A. Y' ^7 c# M7 V4 x2 iPSYCHOLOGIST, a monthly magazine including articles, book reviews, news,6 e0 T0 u- v0 N. }5 L& m
research, updates, and featuring PSYCHOLOGIST APPOINTMENTS, packed0 b0 H3 y# D' F/ ^7 t1 K5 ~1 k; |
with job vacancies every month; STUDENT GROUP, automatic membership to7 v/ I- m2 u# Y' _+ R9 {
the Student Members Group (http://smg.bps.org.uk/); DISCOUNT ON BOOKS
# ]' s0 z9 W* C; c4 ?9 zAND JOURNALS, a range of books, audio, video and other material is" F; t+ O4 k- O& s
published by the society; ACCESS TO THE SOCIETY'S LIBRARY FACILITIES,. J' H' l& s( x. y' y2 {
the library is housed in the [url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url] Library of the University of0 d+ E! z8 K- x' S  i9 Q0 ^
London and is the largest [url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url] library in Europe; REDUCED# n# s4 v$ m0 W3 o4 r
REGISTRATION FEES, for attendance at the Annual and London Conferences.
7 E1 H0 }$ w$ P0 l& q
3 C0 A: I8 h- I# Y----------------------------------------
* x7 V0 f' V2 z  _$ e10. May's Psychologist magazine:2 Z) j2 H7 V. l" U& H0 ]# F7 r
----------------------------------------0 k8 q: K( V. G
" R: f( K8 Y4 A0 f
Articles this month: [url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url] and wine. Working memory in the classroom.
- z4 [" Q4 \- p: X" l# HThe benefits of the bedtime story. Worrying about worrying. Speed dating.7 X0 |/ w0 \/ e6 f' |( O
The benefits of an intermediate [url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url] service.
' b" }( w5 X- j& Z9 }3 U6 f- C/ j- y" k% U' j
Plus interviews, news, reviews, letters, job adverts and much more, The* o. ~! c% A/ c
Psychologist really is the one stop shop for anyone interested in [url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url]
' I1 S/ ^3 Y6 y3 V( P: Shttp://www.thepsychologist.org.uk
3 K# j+ X3 e' z- u  n+ s. [3 w8 L4 f% j
Free to members of the British Psychological Society (see
. e% Y& S% K7 l) }8 X5 Ghttp://www.bps.org.uk/join), or just £4 per copy to Digest subscribers) y" R) m5 M5 |2 @6 t: z8 I. I
(e-mail sarah.stainton@bps.org.uk).3 c* x( ~& {: \7 `  `

" t; F8 u) G/ S, j: R, z/ oONLINE ONLY...breaking news, extra articles, a discussion forum and free) e1 u9 e8 m4 R
access to articles older than 6 months.
+ e' }& u4 v3 F8 W, B
6 a* s/ {7 K$ a) u8 T4 v----------------------------------------
, l1 l4 P0 k$ ~11. Acknowledgments
. ^- q$ S$ j: `6 P! P0 |* z- r" a/ h----------------------------------------
9 e* b# x: j8 G% I& w
+ J1 a! c6 w$ Q' L7 ?Many thanks again to the journals and publishers who participate in the# P: H2 P1 r* P
Research Digest - Blackwell Publishing, Routledge and [url=http://psysoper.com]psychology[/url] Press1 a8 \9 B, i- o$ l( ~
(both Taylor and Francis Group), Oxford University Press, Cambridge. g1 _+ J4 X8 d" i1 r2 w
University Press, John Wiley and Sons Ltd, Nature Neuroscience, Elsevier# r" {6 Q8 N$ }
Ltd, the journal Science, and the journals of the British Psychological* V1 `1 M6 G% U9 V( `+ U
Society./ [' `8 ~/ B2 T* p" g/ R) c

4 f7 x/ G0 g" Q% o" I! \*If you are a publisher and would like your journals to have the chance5 \1 Q3 R8 s% i; O% a0 S- w+ B
to feature here, please contact the editor on:
' z: d7 v. z8 Q: \8 q' j) N4 Vchrber@bps.org.uk
. B+ {: x0 ]9 J$ D1 f1 d( {6 u/ E! ~4 }3 \; h- ~! }
_____________________________
, D. P9 U  a8 ]/ \/ }- j: a2 g' I( B
Please note, the Society cannot accept responsibility for the content of9 H! y3 P- C- ?1 b7 e2 Y" P
external internet sites.
5 f: k% A7 I& c- h& ^7 R! M3 [
% K4 z4 k! \6 X0 f' Q4 G9 j4 Y
- {; d  T4 O- r% }1 r  b% t) zEND of ISSUE
3 v- ~9 C, L8 S' [- U) S* F" B/ g" |

+ g' j* [- h/ e; A0 v+ T( D! Y6 k5 A0 D% F5 {8 n5 R7 D
-----------( G8 \* ~5 C. q3 d, y' Z
The British Psychological Society is a charity registered in England and Wales' e/ `3 p1 q( K5 s5 G
Registration Number : 229642 and a charity registered in Scotland/ D6 Q& c% Z! Q1 Z9 Q$ p
Registration Number : SC039452 - VAT Registration Number : 240 3937 76

TOP

发新话题